Return to Silent Hill Review: When the Fog Clears, There’s Not Much There

By

Return to Silent Hill is directed by Christophe Gans. and the cast includes Jeremy Irvine and Hannah Emily Anderson.

My Thoughts on Return to Silent Hill

Return to Silent Hill is the third film tied to the Silent Hill name, itself borrowed from the long-running video game series by Konami.

Now we all know that video game movies have a reputation that is difficult to escape, and this one doesn’t do much to challenge it, and while there are exceptions in the genre, this film lands closer to the familiar disappointment than the surprise success.

James is a man weighed down by grief after the death of his girlfriend, Mary, and the movie opens with James already hollowed out by loss, and when a letter arrives that appears to be written by Mary, despite her being dead, James doesn’t question the logic for long, as he follows the pull of it back to Silent Hill, a place that seems to exist mainly to punish anyone foolish enough to return.

It's a simple and direct setup, and you become to quickly realize that the film is clearly less interested in realism than it is in mood, and once James enters Silent Hill, there’s a sense that nothing here is neutral, and everything feels hostile.

Silent Hill itself looks unpleasant in a very intentional way, where buildings feel abandoned but not empty, as if something is always watching from just out of sight, and the monsters vary in form and size, and some of them are fairly unsettling, and for brief moments the film finds the discomfort it’s clearly aiming for.

But the visual problems are hard to ignore, as large portions of the movie look artificial, and many scenes appear to rely heavily on fake backgrounds, which makes the actors seem disconnected from their surroundings.

Instead of feeling trapped inside Silent Hill, James often looks like he’s standing in front of it, and these effects don’t blend well with the live action, and the result is distracting, and I really did think that at some points, the image felt unfinished, as if it were waiting for another pass in the editing room that never came.

This artificial look hurts the tone more than anything else though, as horror depends on control, and when the visuals draw attention to themselves for the wrong reasons, the tension collapses, and when you end up thinking about how the scene had been put together in a negative sense, that’s certainly not where the focus should be.

The characters don’t help much either too, as James is emotionally flat, and while that may be intentional, it makes him difficult to care about, as his grief is stated more than it is explored, while Mary is slightly more interesting by comparison, mostly because the film hints at a darker background involving a cult led by her father.

The idea that Silent Hill is shaped by generations of belief and control is an interesting one, but the film never commits to any of it, as the cult exists just enough to suggest depth and then fades into the background.

And that sense of hesitation runs through the entire story — ideas are introduced, then abandoned, themes are suggested, then left undeveloped, and the film seems unsure of what it wants to focus on, as it gestures toward a lot of themes but doesn’t settle on any of them.

While there’s something appropriate about a story set in Silent Hill being disorienting, there’s a difference between confusion that serves a purpose and confusion that feels like poor planning, and here, it leans too far toward the latter.

There is, buried somewhere in this film, a thoughtful story about loss and the inability to let go, and I could see it trying to surface now and then, but unfortunately, those moments are drowned out by uneven pacing and visual noise.

By the time it was over, it all felt like a sense of wasted potential — the setting is strong, some of the creature work is effective, and there are ideas here that could have been shaped into something meaningful.

But it all feels cheap in ways that go beyond budget, messy with the choices made, and undercut what little strength it has.

Return to Silent Hill is very hard to recommend, even for fans of Silent Hill, as it looks rough, sounds confused, and struggles to give its characters any real weight.

Whatever reason there was to return to Silent Hill, the film doesn’t make a strong case for why it needed to happen this way.

What are your thoughts on Return to Silent Hill? Join me on Threads, Instagram or Facebook, and Reddit.