Pathetic Fallacy Sounds Like a Very Strange Horror Trip

Pathetic Fallacy movie poster

Pathetic Fallacy sounds completely ridiculous when you try to explain it properly, so bear with me - Scott Mescudi, better known as Kid Cudi, plays a grieving widower named Asher who loses his wife Iris, played by Jessica Rothe, and ends up traveling to a strange mountain town looking for some kind of answer to what happened. 

He finds a lot more than he bargained for though, including a homicidal stranger, demonic forest spirits, talking animals and the possibility of somehow cheating death, and that is only the basic setup, because Adam Egypt Mortimer's new movie gets considerably stranger once Asher reaches Mount Samdi, turning what starts as a story about losing someone you love into a psychedelic horror trip that mixes supernatural horror, romance, dark comedy and musical sequences without seeming particularly interested in sticking to any one of them.

A Love Story That Goes Somewhere Very Bad

Asher and Iris are introduced as a couple who are genuinely in love, which turns out to be important because Pathetic Fallacy spends a lot of time making you understand what Asher has lost rather than simply using Iris's death as an excuse to start the horror - the two meet at a karaoke bar and connect over a shared performance, building a relationship that is deliberately sweet before everything falls apart. 

And then movie apparently really starts going off the rails, where the entire world starts becoming increasingly unreliable as Asher's grief takes over.

He encounters Doyle, a violent and unpredictable character played by Travis Fimmel, while Natasha Lyonne voices a talking black widow spider who becomes involved in Asher's desperate attempt to find a way back to Iris - there are also talking animals, supernatural forces and sudden musical performances, with the movie gradually turning into something that is much closer to a fever dream than a conventional horror story.

Kid Cudi Leads a Very Strange Movie

Scott Mescudi has acted before, but this is his first starring role, and the reaction from Fantastic Fest has been particularly strong, as several reviews have pointed to his performance as the thing holding the movie together when the story becomes increasingly strange.

Johnny Jewel provides the original score for the film, while Mescudi contributes original music to the film. - has Jewel described the project as a grief-horror-psychedelic film and said the music moves through everything from doom metal and trip hop to 1940s big-band jazz alongside his electronic work.

Mortimer has also explained that the musical aspect wasn't originally part of the screenplay, as the idea developed after he read the script and started thinking about the story of Orpheus, which gave him the idea of using music as part of Asher's journey to try to get his wife back.

The film was also shot on 35mm, which fits the deliberately heightened look Mortimer was going for.

A Very Different Kind of Horror Movie

Mortimer has previously directed Some Kind of Hate, Archenemy and Daniel Isn't Real, so anyone expecting a completely straightforward supernatural horror movie probably wasn't paying attention - Pathetic Fallacy seems to be his most deliberately strange film yet. 

Pathetic Fallacy was written by Andrew Barrer and Gabriel Ferrari, with Mortimer directing. - the cast includes Scott Mescudi, Jessica Rothe, Travis Fimmel and Natasha Lyonne, alongside Richard Harmon, Jess Brown, Amitai Marmorstein and others.

The film was produced through companies including Mad Solar Productions, Room 101, Rabbits Black, Hadron Films, Lovesick Pictures and Still Point Productions, while the producers include Steven Schneider, K. Asher Levin, Ronnie Exley, Karina Manashil, Chris Wilkinson, Aria Moffly and Ashleigh Snead, with Mescudi among the executive producers.

There is currently no confirmed general release date or distributor announced, with the film making its world premiere at Fantastic Fest in September 2026.

Pathetic Fallacy movie still 1

Pathetic Fallacy movie still 2

Pathetic Fallacy movie still 3

[Pathetic Fallacy on IMDb]

Are you looking forward to Pathetic Fallacy? Join me on Threads, Instagram, Facebook, and Reddit.